July 25, 2020

👭 Knight Challenge #11 👬

Want to try your hand at these challenges? There's a couple of things you can do!
From writing, to research, to images, find your preferred way to contribute with our eleventh theme: Couples!

Latest Announcements

Zelda Wiki:Failed Nominations/Picture

From Zelda Wiki, the Zelda encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Failed Picture Nominations

The following sections are picture nominations which either expired or received a score of -3.

Lightsword.jpg — Failed April 3, 2008
1243690847 64601fc368.jpg — Failed April 4, 2008
Hidden11.jpg — Failed April 29, 2008
Zant012.jpg — Failed May 8, 2008
Spinattack.jpg — Failed May 8, 2008
Mastersword.jpeg — Failed May 10, 2008
DLGanon TP.jpg — May 11, 2008
Darkhyrulecastle.jpg — Failed due to invalid nomination
Kingofredlions.gif — Failed May 17, 2008
TP Twilit Bloat Render.png — Failed June 17, 2008
Desertcolossus.jpg — Failed June 28, 2008
Link evo.jpg — Failed July 6, 2008
TP Ganon Render.png — Failed August 6, 2008
Darkhyrulecastle.jpg (nomination 2) — Failed due to invalid nomination
Master Sword.png — Failed August 21, 2008, withdrawn by nominating user
Emptybottle.png — Failed August 20, 2008
Hidden11.jpg — Failed August 31, 2008
JumpTwilight.jpg — Failed September 10, 2008
gohma early.jpg — October 3, 2008
TP Death Sword Render.png (proposed replacement for Deathhh.jpg) — Failed on October 16, 2008
MM Deku Royal Family Artwork.png — Failed on November 11, 2008
LA Great Hyrulean Sea Storm Artwork.png — Failed on November 17, 2008
PH Scene 1-2.png/Ph scene 1b.jpg — Failed on November 18, 2008
Link and Ezlo.png — Failed on November 18, 2008
Twilight Sword.png — Failed on February 22, 2009
TRR Tingle 2.png — Failed on March 11, 2009
MM Twinmold Artwork.png — Failed on April 14, 2009

{{hide|header=PhantomHourglassscene13.png (Bellumbeck) — Failed on April 18, 2009 |content=


This picture is from the ending sequence of Phantom Hourglass. I think it's style is pretty neat.--Link hero of light 16:26, 28 March 2009 (UTC)

Support Vote.png Support
  1. This is a great picture showcasing the artstyle of Phantom Hourglass's cutscenes. I major Yes. -ATRUEZELDAFAN 13:32, 31 March 2009 (UTC)
  2. PH has no featured pictures yet, this is worthy on it it's own, it reflects the action and style of the game very nicely. Much more than being a nice image, it's the perfect example of what can be expected from Ph's innocent appearance and fearsome phantoms. Axiomist (talk) 06:44, 8 April 2009 (UTC)
  3. An awesome picture, very stylish and cool looking. Also, a nice action scene. Axle the Beast 04:10, 11 April 2009 (UTC)
  4. I love this style and tried to do something like that, too. And therefore I can say that this picture is one of the best from the cutscences and not as simple, as it may seem. And also, if PH doesn't have any featured pictures yet, this is another point for it. --Nelde 18:39, 12 April 2009 (UTC)
  5. This is a really good picture from what is perhaps one of the best portable games ever. It shows all the dynamic emotion and styles that were used in the game, as well as how the boss is fought, in a sort of vauge way.--Petman1325 20:14, 15 April 2009 (UTC)
  6. The Phantom Hourglass cut out style is so unique!Corey Lord of Tacos! 02:02, 18 April 2009 (UTC)
Symbol oppose vote.png Opposition
  1. This image is incredibly small. It is much smaller than most of our currently featured images. Plus it is one image out of many that are very similar to it. Doesn't really strike me as awesome. Not compared to what we have.User:Matt/sig 21:47, April 15, 2009 (UTC)
  2. I agree with Matt. Although Bellumbeck is awesome, this cutout doesn't stand out from the others in my opinion and doesn't really seem like much compared to other nominees. Kind of droll really. Then there's the size. {{:User:Melchizedek1866/sig 04:12, 16 April 2009 (UTC)
  3. Bellumbeck would have made a good featured picture however, this image is incredibly small. Hardly eye catching or even interesting. Not really feature worthy.User:Mandi/sig 02:21, 18 April 2009 (UTC)
Symbol neutral vote.png Neutral Comments

Size is reason enough to not vote for it, but hardly justifiable to Oppose an image. The Images above are all great but Opposition votes with the reason of "We already have several very similar images featured." would fit in the rules as stated above. Just bear that in mind before Failing this image. Axiomist (talk) 04:23, 16 April 2009 (UTC)

I as well, will not oppose this image, we have had Phantom Hourglass nominations before. I'd hate to see this one fail because of my vote, but it's certainly not featured material. First of all, Link hero of light, when Matt and Mel told you the image is too small, they meant the image itself; increasing the thumbnail size will do no good. Also by "large", they mean LARGE at least 900px in height, and size of an image does matter (large images give the "wow factor"). Even in the guidelines it states "it's too low resolution" as one of the examples as a justifiable opposition.Steve 20:31, 16 April 2009 (UTC)


{{hide|header=Epona w link.png (Link with Epona) — Failed on October 1, 2009|content=

OoT Link Riding Epona Artwork.png

This is a very cool image that needs to be featured. There are not very many Epona pictures but I think this one is the best. It really captures the image of Ocarina of Time. It is very nicely drawn and old school. It needs to be featured.--Lt. Hammerspace 03:30, 29 September 2009 (UTC)

Support Vote.png Support
Symbol oppose vote.png Opposition
  1. Eh...my first and real gripe with this image is the quality. It seems choppy and the transparency job is rather poor. It's also rather uninteresting.User:Mandi/sig 04:39, 30 September 2009 (UTC)
  2. The transparency job is done badly, but the image also offers nothing special. It is rather stock-standard, not encapsulating any mood or interest. It doesn't draw people in. {{:User:Melchizedek1866/sig 04:11, 1 October 2009 (UTC)
  3. There are several visible leftovers from a quick and somewhat sloppy transparency job. The tail seems a little choppy and it looks like the sword is missing a few pixels. The tail and mane also look like parts are missing as well as having some background left over. As far as I'm concerned this isn't the highest of quality.User:Matt/sig 04:32, October 1, 2009 (UTC)
Negated.png Negated/Retracted Votes
  1. I absolutely love it. Great image. Alter  {T C B H } 05:37, 29 September 2009 (UTC) Vote withdrawn. Alter  {T C B H } 18:14, 30 September 2009 (UTC)
Symbol neutral vote.png Neutral Comments
  1. Clean it up, and then we'll talk. Also, doesn't Link know it's dangerous to lean back on a horse while it's rearing? Noble Wrot 05:41, 29 September 2009 (UTC)
  1. The image doesn't look that great now that I know what it is. It's not bad, but not featured quality. Alter  {T C B H } 18:14, 30 September 2009 (UTC)


Link and Ezlo Still Life.png (Link and Ezlo Still Life) — Failed on May 10, 2010
ST Link Phantom Zelda Spirit Train Artwork.png (Spirit Tracks Artwork) — Failed on July 28, 2010
LinkImpa.png (Link and Impa) — Failed on September 13, 2010
Ambrosia Lite.png (Ambrosia Lite) — Failed on October 7, 2010
Great Deku Tree.png (Great Deku Tree) — Failed on February 25, 2011
File:PhantomHourglassscene10.png — Failed on February 28, 2012
File:Mirror of Twilight (Front).png - Failed on July 12, 2012
File:SS Faron Woods Artwork.png (Scenery from Skyward Sword) — Failed on July 10, 2011
File:Triforce.jpg (Artwork of the Triforce from A Link to the Past) — Failed on December 20, 2012
File:TWW JP Box.jpg The Wind Waker Japanese boxart — Failed on March 16, 2013
File:Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 4.33.27 PM.png Master Sword Fan Art — Failed on March 16, 2013
File:Linkinwiiu.png (Link in the Zelda HD Experience) — Failed on March 17, 2013
File:TWW HD.jpg (The Wind Waker HD Screenshot)
File:ALBW Hyrule Lorule.png (A Link Between Worlds Artwork) — Failed on June 14, 2014 (expired)